The 10 Best Restaurants in St. Thomas (Updated July 2025)

As a traveler to the beautiful island of St. Thomas, you’re likely looking for an exceptional dining experience that showcases the local flavors and culture. After extensive research and reviews from fellow travelers and locals alike, we’ve compiled a list of the top 10 restaurants in St. Thomas that are sure to impress even the most discerning palate.

Introduction

St. Thomas, part of the US Virgin Islands, is renowned for its stunning beaches, crystal-clear waters, and vibrant culture. The island’s culinary scene reflects its rich history, with influences from African, European, and Caribbean traditions. In this article, we’ll guide you through the best restaurants in St. Thomas, highlighting their unique offerings, ambiance, and what sets them apart.

1. The Fish Trap

Located on the picturesque Magens Bay Beach, The Fish Trap is a local favorite that serves up fresh seafood in an elegant setting. Their menu features a variety of fish dishes, including sushi-grade options, as well as traditional Caribbean favorites like conch fritters and jerk chicken.

2. La Tapa

For a taste of Europe on the island, head to La Tapa, which offers an upscale dining experience with a focus on seasonal ingredients. Their menu changes frequently, but expect dishes like paella, tapas, and modern takes on classic Spanish cuisine.

3. The St. Thomas Food and Wine Experience

This unique restaurant combines fine dining with local flavors and live music. The menu features a range of Caribbean-inspired dishes, including vegetarian and vegan options, all paired with an impressive wine list.

4. Mikes Seaside Grille

With its stunning views of the harbor, Mike’s Seaside Grille is perfect for a romantic dinner or special occasion. Their menu focuses on fresh seafood, steaks, and pasta dishes, all prepared to perfection.

5. The Ritz-Carlton’s Hemingway’s

Located within the luxurious Ritz-Carlton resort, Hemingway’s offers an elegant dining experience inspired by the works of Ernest Hemingway. The menu features a range of international dishes, including seafood, steak, and pasta options.

6. La Bodega

For a taste of authentic Cuban cuisine, head to La Bodega, which serves up traditional dishes like lechon asado, arroz con pollo, and empanadas. Their outdoor seating area is perfect for people-watching.

7. The Boathouse:

Located on the waterfront, The Boathouse offers stunning views of the harbor while serving up fresh seafood and steaks. Their menu features a range of options, including sushi-grade fish, lobster rolls, and burgers.

8. 99 Steps Restaurant

This family-friendly restaurant is perfect for families or groups looking for a casual dining experience. Their menu features a range of local favorites, including conch fritters, jerk chicken, and seafood paella.

9. The Galleon.

For a unique dining experience, head to The Galleon, which offers a pirate-themed restaurant with live music and entertainment. Their menu features a range of international dishes, including seafood, steak, and pasta options.

10. La Tastadora

This modern Spanish tapas bar is perfect for a night out with friends or a date. Their menu features a range of small plates, including tortilla española, croquetas, and patatas bravas.

Conclusion

St. Thomas offers a diverse range of dining options that cater to every taste and budget. From fine dining experiences to casual eateries, these top 10 restaurants showcase the best of the island’s cuisine. Whether you’re looking for fresh seafood, local flavors, or international cuisine, there’s something for everyone in St. Thomas.

What’s on your culinary bucket list for St. Thomas? Share with us in the comments below!

Top 10 St Thomas Eateries Updated July 2025