The US Virgin Islands are a culinary haven for foodies, with its rich cultural heritage and tropical climate providing an ideal environment for a wide variety of delicious dishes to flourish. While many visitors flock to the islands’ more popular restaurants and resorts, there are numerous hidden gems that remain off the beaten path. In this post, we’ll explore ten of these lesser-known culinary treasures on St. Croix, revealing the island’s best-kept secrets.

Hidden Gem #1: A Taste of Africa

Located in the heart of Christiansted, Mango Tango is a unique restaurant serving up African-inspired dishes with a Caribbean twist. Their menu features items such as jerk chicken and plantains, goat curry, and suya (grilled meat skewers). The restaurant’s intimate setting and live music add to its charm.

Practical Example

Try their signature dish, the Mango Tango Burger, which combines grilled beef, mango salsa, and crispy bacon on a toasted baguette. Wash it down with a glass of their homemade Mango Lassi – a refreshing blend of yogurt, mango puree, and spices.

Hidden Gem #2: Fresh Seafood

St. Croix is renowned for its fresh seafood, and The Fish Trap is a local favorite that offers an unparalleled dining experience. This casual eatery serves up an array of seafood dishes, including fish sandwiches, lobster rolls, and even alligator bites (for the adventurous).

Practical Example

Be sure to try their Fish Fry, which features a daily catch prepared with love and care. Choose from a variety of flavors such as lemon butter, garlic parmesan, or spicy Cajun seasoning.

Hidden Gem #3: Island-Style BBQ

Rhythms at the Beach is a laid-back beachside restaurant that serves up mouthwatering barbecue dishes with an island twist. Their menu features items like jerk chicken, ribs, and even alligator sausage (for those who dare).

Practical Example

Try their Jerk Chicken, which is marinated in a secret blend of herbs and spices before being grilled to perfection. Pair it with a side of their creamy Coconut Rice.

Hidden Gem #4: Local Fruits and Vegetables

St. Croix Farmers Market is a hidden gem that offers a wide variety of fresh fruits, vegetables, and local products. This bustling market is the perfect place to stock up on ingredients for your own culinary creations.

Practical Example

Visit the market early in the morning to snag some Fresh Mangoes, which are ripe and ready to eat. Pair them with a slice of St. Croix Bread – a sweet, crusty loaf made from locally-sourced ingredients.

Hidden Gem #5: Unique Desserts

The Chocolate Company is a must-visit for any chocoholic. This family-owned business offers an array of decadent desserts, including chocolate-covered strawberries, brownies, and even chocolate-dipped bacon.

Practical Example

Try their Chocolate-Dipped Pineapple, which combines sweet and tangy flavors in a way that will leave you wanting more. Pair it with a glass of their rich Hot Chocolate for the ultimate treat.

Hidden Gem #6: Artisanal Cocktails

The Galleon is a swanky cocktail bar located in Christiansted’s historic district. Their menu features an array of creative cocktails made with fresh ingredients and local spirits.

Practical Example

Try their signature drink, The Croix, which combines rum, mango puree, lime juice, and ginger beer for a refreshing taste that’s both sweet and tangy.

Hidden Gem #7: Live Music

Rhythms at the Beach is not only a great spot for barbecue, but also live music. This beachside restaurant hosts local musicians on weekends, making it the perfect spot to enjoy some tunes while soaking up the island vibes.

Practical Example

Visit Rhythms at the Beach on a Saturday night and enjoy the sounds of a local band playing a mix of reggae, rock, and pop music. Pair it with a plate of their delicious barbecue and you’re in for a treat.

Hidden Gem #8: Local Wine

St. Croix Winery is a small but charming winery that produces an array of wines using locally-sourced grapes. Take a tour of the facility and sample some of their delicious offerings.

Practical Example

Try their Mango Wine, which combines sweet and tangy flavors in a way that will leave you wanting more. Pair it with a plate of cheese, crackers, or fruit for the ultimate snack.

Hidden Gem #9: Unique Experiences

The St. Croix Heritage Trail is a self-guided tour that takes visitors through some of the island’s most historic sites, including plantations and museums.

Practical Example

Visit Fort Christiansvaern, a historic fort located in Christiansted. Take a guided tour to learn about its rich history and enjoy stunning views of the surrounding area.

Hidden Gem #10: Island-Style Breakfast

The Breakfast Club is a casual eatery that serves up delicious breakfast dishes with an island twist. Their menu features items like mango pancakes, coconut French toast, and even alligator bites (for the adventurous).

Practical Example

Try their Mango Pancakes, which are made with fresh mango puree and topped with whipped cream, maple syrup, and a sprinkle of cinnamon.

In conclusion, St. Croix is a culinary haven that offers something for everyone – from delicious seafood to unique desserts, artisanal cocktails, and even alligator bites (for the adventurous). By visiting these hidden gems, you’ll experience the island’s rich cultural heritage and tropical climate in a way that will leave you feeling like a true local.